FootJoy WeatherSof Review: The All-Conditions Glove

The FootJoy WeatherSof is the right glove for most recreational golfers who play in variable conditions: FiberSof synthetic body, cabretta leather palm patch, excellent dry grip, strong light-to-moderate wet grip, and a durability figure of 15 to 20-plus rounds per independent reviewer consensus. It isn't the glove for golfers who play five rounds a year in perfect weather and prioritize the feel of all-cabretta leather. Order one size up from your normal glove size: it runs approximately half a size small.

Specs

Grip performance

In dry conditions, the FiberSof body performs well: published review data from Golf Monthly and Golfalot describe grip quality as excellent across a full round, with no slippage reported as hand temperature rises or grip pressure increases through a round. FiberSof's synthetic construction maintains its surface texture as it warms, unlike bare-rubber or entry-level all-synthetic materials.

In light to moderate wet, the WeatherSof's hybrid construction is a structural advantage over all-leather alternatives. Cabretta leather is the benchmark for dry-condition feel, but it absorbs moisture and stiffens: a saturated cabretta glove can feel rigid and lose grip texture within a few holes in damp weather. FiberSof absorbs light moisture without stiffening, which is why the WeatherSof outperforms leather in conditions below a full downpour.

The caveat is the PowerNet mesh. The back-hand and knuckle panels use an open mesh design for breathability and flex. In sustained heavy rain, water enters through the mesh and soaks the interior. This is a water-resistant construction, not a waterproof one. The grip performance in heavy downpours is meaningfully reduced. Golfers who regularly play in British-summer conditions or Pacific Northwest late-season weather should treat the WeatherSof as a dry-to-light-wet glove and carry a backup or look at a dedicated waterproof category.

Durability and construction

Independent reviewer consensus from Golf Monthly, Golfalot, and Amazon aggregated reviews converges on 15 to 20-plus rounds before the palm shows meaningful wear. The cabretta leather patch at the high-friction palm and thumb contact zones is consistently credited for this; the cabretta's natural durability in those locations extends the glove's usable life well past what an all-synthetic palm would deliver.

FootJoy states that the WeatherSof lasts twice as long as a leather glove and cites over 90 million units sold globally. Both claims are manufacturer-stated and framed here as such; neither has been independently measured. What the independent reviewer consensus does support is that the WeatherSof's durability is best-in-category at its price bracket, and that golfers who rotate between two gloves rather than running one to failure typically extend per-glove life further.

The ComforTab closure draws no complaints in review literature. It secures cleanly, holds through a round, and adjusts without cutting into the back of the hand. Functionally, it's the standard for the category.

Sizing, fit, and the cadet option

The WeatherSof runs approximately half a size small across the standard range. This is documented in Golf Monthly's sizing notes and corroborated by a consistent pattern in Amazon reviewer feedback. The fix is simple: order one size up from your normal glove size. If you normally wear a medium, order ML.

The cadet fit deserves specific mention. Cadet sizing addresses a hand shape with a wider palm and shorter fingers relative to standard sizing. FootJoy offers the WeatherSof cadet range across S, M, ML, L, and XL, a fuller range than most major brands offer at this price point. Golfers who have struggled with standard gloves bunching at the knuckles or pulling at the palm are the target for cadet sizing, and the WeatherSof is one of the more accessible options for that fit profile.

One sourcing note on cadet: cadet stock availability can vary by retailer and season, and some third-party Amazon listings have been reported as fulfilling a standard order with a cadet unit. Purchase from Amazon-fulfilled (FBA) stock and verify the listing confirms the fit type before ordering.

A note on the 1-star rapid-wear cluster

There is a cluster of 1-star Amazon reviews of the WeatherSof citing glove failure within one to two rounds, which is in direct conflict with the 15-to-20-round figure the independent reviewers and the wider Amazon consensus support. The gap between those two data sets is, in my read of the pattern, cleanly attributable to the sourcing channel rather than any WeatherSof material defect. The rapid-wear cluster traces consistently to third-party marketplace sellers (gray-market or counterfeit units) rather than Amazon-fulfilled stock. This is a documented Amazon marketplace problem that extends across many high-volume sporting goods products, not a WeatherSof quality verdict.

The practical implication: filter for Amazon-fulfilled (FBA) listings when ordering, or purchase directly through FootJoy or a verified sporting goods retailer. The durability data for FBA-sourced WeatherSof stock is consistent with the 15-to-20-plus-round figure across independent review sources.

Who it's for; who should skip it

Buy it if: you play in variable conditions (including damp mornings, light rain, or high-heat rounds where hand sweat is a factor), you play regularly enough that per-round cost matters, or your current glove is wearing through in fewer than 15 rounds. The WeatherSof's hybrid construction gives it the grip range and durability to be the single glove most recreational golfers use across a full season.

Skip it if: you play five rounds a year or fewer in consistently dry conditions and the feel priority is thin all-cabretta leather. The Titleist Players is the correct call for that profile: it delivers the best dry-condition feel in the category, and at that round frequency, the durability advantage of the WeatherSof carries no practical value.

FootJoy WeatherSof on Amazon

How it compares

*Durability figures from published review sources; competitor figures are reviewer estimates, not manufacturer data.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size FootJoy WeatherSof glove should I order?

Is the FootJoy WeatherSof waterproof?

How many rounds does the FootJoy WeatherSof last?

Are there counterfeit FootJoy WeatherSof gloves on Amazon?

How does the FootJoy WeatherSof compare to the Titleist Players glove?

Some links in this review are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences what I cover or recommend. I link to gear I'd buy myself.