how-to
How to Set Ball Position for Every Club
Ball position isn't a single spot you set once and reuse for every club in the
How to Stop Coming Over the Top
The downswing drills that fix your transition, whether it's costing you slices, pulls, or fat and thin contact.
If you're slicing the ball, start with the face, not the path. Two pieces already on this site, How to Fix a Golf Slice and Why Your Driver Slices When Your Irons Don't, lay out why clubface angle controls most of a shot's starting direction and why grip and setup come before path work in any real fix. This piece picks up after that. It's for the swing flaw that survives a squared-up face: the pull that starts left of target and never comes back, the slice that's still bending 20 yards (18m) or more right even after grip and alignment are sorted, and the fat or thin contact that shows up when the sequence between backswing and downswing breaks down. That flaw has a name. It's coming over the top, and it lives in the transition, not the face.
- 1.The problem starts in transition. Coming over the top happens when the upper body restarts the downswing before the lower body has cleared out of the way, throwing the club onto a steep, outside path.
- 2.The pump drill rehearses the correct transition move with no ball and no equipment.
- 3.Step-and-swing uses footwork to force the lower body to move first, since the swing physically can't continue without the step.
- 4.An impact bag shows you the actual path of the clubhead through the ball, not just where the shot ends up.
- 5.An alignment stick under the lead armpit gives instant feedback the moment the upper body fires early.
What coming over the top actually is
"Over the top" describes a downswing that starts from the shoulders and arms instead of the hips. The club gets thrown outward and down from a steep angle, which sends it into the ball from outside the target line moving across it, rather than from inside the line moving down it. What happens at contact from there depends on what the clubface is doing, which is exactly why the face-first pieces linked above matter: an open face on that outside-in path produces a slice, a square or closed face on the same path produces a pull, and either way the steep angle of attack is a common source of fat and thin contact, since the low point of the swing arrives before or after the ball instead of right on it.
The move is common enough that it shows up across handicap levels, not just among beginners, and it can cost real distance even on the shots it doesn't send offline, since a low point that arrives 6 inches (15cm) early or late bleeds ball speed compared to a strike right on center. It's a timing problem more than a strength or flexibility problem, which is good news: it responds to drilling.
The kinematic sequence: why the lower body has to start first
Motion-capture research from the Titleist Performance Institute (TPI) describes an efficient downswing as a chain reaction that runs from the ground up: the pelvis starts rotating toward the target first, the torso follows and catches up to the pelvis, the arms follow the torso, and the club follows the arms, each segment reaching its peak rotational speed slightly after the one before it. That ground-up order, sometimes called proximal-to-distal sequencing, is what lets the club accelerate through impact using speed handed down from the body rather than speed generated by the arms alone.
Coming over the top reverses that order. The arms and shoulders fire first, before the hips have started clearing toward the target, so the club gets thrown from the top of the backswing instead of pulled down and around by a body that's already turning. Whether your driver swings at 80 mph (129km/h) or 105 mph (169km/h), the sequencing problem is the same: the upper body is doing a job the lower body was supposed to start.
That's the piece a drill needs to isolate: not the swing plane on its own, but the order the body parts fire in during the half-second of transition at the top of the swing.
Drills that retrain the transition
Work through these in order. The first two need no equipment at all, which matters if you're practicing at home or don't want to add gear before you know the sequencing fix is actually the problem. The second two add feedback tools that confirm whether the change is real or just a feeling.
1. The pump drill
- Take your setup with a mid-iron. A ball is optional; this drill works fine rehearsed with no ball at all.
- Swing to the top of your backswing as normal.
- From the top, without swinging through, lower the club about halfway down, to roughly waist height, about 3 feet (0.9m) off the ground, then raise it back to the top. Do this two or three times.
- As you pump the club down, feel your hips and lower body shift and rotate toward the target before your arms and hands drop. That shift is the move you're training.
- On the last pump, let the swing continue through to a full finish.
- Work in sets of 10 reps, focusing entirely on the sensation of the hips leading rather than on where the ball goes.
2. Step-and-swing
- Set up with your feet closer together than normal, or with your lead foot (left foot for a right-handed golfer) lifted slightly off the ground.
- Start your backswing from that narrow or lifted-foot position.
- As you reach the top and begin the downswing, step your lead foot back into a normal stance width, moving it toward the target by about 6 inches (15cm).
- Let that step be the trigger that starts the downswing. The swing physically can't continue in the right order until the foot lands, which forces the lower body to move first.
- Swing through to a full finish and repeat for 10 reps before hitting any balls.
3. Impact bag direction feedback
An impact bag shows you something a ball flight can't always tell you on its own: the actual direction the clubhead is traveling at the moment it makes contact. A Gary Wiren-designed impact bag is a stitched, sand-filled bag built to absorb a full-speed strike without damaging the club, so you can swing at real intent rather than pulling up short the way you would hitting into a towel on the ground.
- Set the bag about 2 feet (0.6m) in front of your normal ball position, at the spot where the ball would sit.
- Make three-quarter-speed swings into the bag, stopping the club at the moment of contact rather than swinging through.
- Read the impression the club leaves on the bag. A mark angled steeply across the bag, running from outside the target line to inside it, confirms an out-to-in path consistent with coming over the top. A mark that's square to the target, or angled slightly the other way, confirms the path has moved inside.
- Work in sets of 10, and only increase swing speed once the direction of the mark holds steady at the slower speed.
4. Alignment stick under the lead armpit
An alignment stick doubles as one of the cheapest feedback tools in golf, and a set of alignment sticks covers this drill and the swing-plane check that follows it with the same pair of rods.
- Tuck one end of an alignment stick under your lead armpit, gripping the club normally with the stick trapped against your side by your upper arm.
- Make slow, half-speed backswings and downswings, keeping the stick pinned against your body until just before impact.
- If the stick pops loose early in the downswing, that's your upper body firing before your lower body has started clearing, the same fault the pump drill and step-and-swing are training out.
- Once the stick stays pinned through several reps, add a second stick pushed into the ground about 12 inches (30cm) outside the ball, angled along your correct downswing path, as a swing-plane rail. If the clubhead swings wide of that rail in transition, the fault is still live even if the first stick stayed put.
For a companion drill built specifically around the tempo and sequencing of the transition itself, the Orange Whip full-size trainer is already reviewed on this site and worth reading alongside these four drills rather than as a separate purchase.
Which drill actually transfers to the course
Range gains and course gains aren't automatically the same thing, and coaching literature on motor learning generally favors drills that keep some connection to a real ball and a real target over drills that only train a feeling in isolation. On that measure, the impact bag and the pump drill tend to hold up best, since both keep you swinging at something resembling full speed and intent. If forced to rank the four for how well they carry over once a scorecard and a real target 150 yards (137m) away are involved, I'd put the alignment-stick-under-the-armpit drill last, not because the feedback is wrong, but because it's easy to let the stick police the position for you instead of building your own sense of the sequence, so it's worth treating as an early diagnostic step you wean off rather than something to keep leaning on at full speed.
None of these drills fix a slice on their own if the face is still open at impact. They fix the transition. Pair them with the face-angle work in the two linked articles above and the path change actually shows up in ball flight instead of just on the range.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is coming over the top the same thing as a slice?
No. Coming over the top describes the club's path in the downswing, moving from outside the target line to inside it. Whether that produces a slice, a pull, or straight but fat and thin contact depends on what the clubface is doing at impact, which is a separate fix covered in How to Fix a Golf Slice.
How many reps of these drills does it take before it shows up on real shots?
There's no fixed number that applies to every golfer, since it depends on how ingrained the old sequence is. Most golfers need repeated short sessions, several sets of 10 reps at a time, over multiple practice visits rather than one long session, with the impact bag or alignment stick used to confirm the change is real before testing it on full shots.
Can I do any of these drills without buying equipment?
Yes. The pump drill and step-and-swing both need nothing but a club and enough room to swing it, and either works fine at home with no ball. They're the right starting point before adding an impact bag or alignment sticks to confirm the change is holding.
How far outside the ball should the second alignment stick go for the swing-plane check?
About 12 inches (30cm) outside the ball, pushed into the ground and angled along your intended downswing path. If the clubhead clips the stick or swings wide of it during the downswing, the over-the-top pattern is still present even if the armpit feedback felt clean.
Does fixing the transition help with fat and thin contact too, not just slices and pulls?
Yes. An outside-in, over-the-top path changes where the low point of the swing arrives relative to the ball, which is a common cause of catching the ground before the ball (fat contact) or catching the ball on the upswing (thin contact). These four drills target the transition itself, so the benefit isn't limited to one type of miss.
If you'd rather work through a structured, session-by-session way to confirm a swing change like this one has actually transferred from range to course before you trust it under pressure, The 10-Shot Validation Check walks through a simple pass-fail counting method built for exactly that problem.
Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences what I cover or recommend. I link to gear I'd buy myself.
The golf newsletter that cuts the hype
Data-backed reviews and advice that works. No brand spin.
